Premium Quality Dog Food – Is It Worth The Extra Money?

By on May 24, 2012

"Premium Quality Food Product or Premium Price for Fancy Marketing?"

The dog is an animal from the order 'Carnivora'. In other words a meat eater. We humans are omnivorous, in other words we'll eat just about anything that's put in front of us. Dogs eat meat, we eat all foods. But have you ever noticed that many dogs pay no heed to their scientific description as Carnivores?

Premium quality dog food - is it worth it

In fact, there are a good many dogs who couldn't give two hoots as to whether it's flesh, fruit, fish or Fray Bentos pies that they are throwing down their necks.

So it could be argued that a dog is better described as omnivorous as we are, certainly not a true carnivore in the same sense as it’s feline counterpart.

We know that dogs can survive on a vegetarian diet, there are even tales of runaway domestic dogs surviving on a diet of fallen apples and other fruits for weeks on end.

They'll scoff just about anything, they can survive so why dog pet food companies insist that they need to spend millions and millions of pounds investigating the science behind a finely balanced doggy dinner?

Dry, or complete dog food as it is better known, has been around for a lot longer than most people realise. It is only in the last 10 to 15 years that the market for anything other wet (tinned meat) dog food has been a regular on the British pet owner's weekly or monthly shopping list.

Think back 10 years if you will, remember the TV ads of the era? How many commercials were show promoting the latest life stage products, premium quality formula's, science diets and the so on? Remember mixer? Do you see many ads for mixer now?

It’s a reflection of the advances made within the pet food sector that all in one, complete pet food is gradually replacing the traditional ‘meat and mixer’ dogs dinner.

The sales figures bear testament to the decline of pet food mixer. In 1991 British pet owners spent ?71m on mixer however in 2000 the mixer market was valued at just ?46m. In stark contrast, the dry / complete dog food market has enjoyed a meteoric rise in popularity being valued at more than ?270m in 2000 compared to ?51m in 1987.*

The pet food industry in the United Kingdom was born at the hands of a lighting conductor salesman from Cincinnati, Ohio. It is reported that a ship docked in England just before the turn of the 20th Century and a passenger by the name of Mr. James Spratt had his attention caught by the sight of dogs scavenging for discarded ships' biscuits on the quayside. In this moment Mr. Spratt had his eyes opened to the opportunity of producing some form of specially prepared pet food.

Spratt embarked on a new career and within 50 years, millions of British and European pet owners were feeding their animals on a prepared diet, developed specifically for pets. In 1957 the first ever 'dry' or extruded pet food was developed in America and in the year 2000, the market value for pet in North America was $11.6bn, seeing a major increase in demand for ‘higher quality’ or premium rated products.

Pet food is in a unique position as a consumer commodity for it is not the purchaser who is the ultimate consumer. Bearing in mind that the vast majority of pet food consumers are, how shall we say, 'fairly easy to please', it is unsurprising that most owners discover a food that their pet likes and sticks to it.

After all, why change when the tail wags so hard and the drool and subsequent mouth wiping on the carpet pays testament to a very satisfied customer?

People are becoming far more aware of the benefits of eating a balanced, healthy diet. Us humans are well catered for, science has shown us the way and we understand the responsibilities on us to eat well, exercise regularly and keep a close eye on the calories.

Dogs on the other hand are not so fortunate as they, quite simply, have to eat what we decide to give them. You are what you eat, as the saying rightly informs us and this is just as true for dogs as it is for ourselves.

As we removed them from the wild we do have an ultimate responsibility to ensure our dogs eat a balanced, nutrtional diet and lead as healthy a lifestyle as we are able to provide. On the whole, do pet owners do this at present? Honestly?

The fact that a reported 50% of British pets are overweight or clinically obese would indicate not. Far from the problem of underfeeding and malnourishment, British pets are faced with the serious danger of obesity, heart disease and various other associated problems.

Just as it is with children, our dogs are getting fatter and maybe it's time to look at the genuine advances being made in the pet food industry.

Millions upon millions of pounds are pumped into the research of pet nutrition by food manufacturers every year. The quest to develop the most effective pet food products to cater specifically for particular breeds, life stages, states of health etc is seemingly un-ending. And guess what? It's not cheap either.

The pet food manufacturing industry is more competitive today than it has ever been, so-called premium quality diets are heavily promoted in the media, the drive for new customers from competing manufacturers is intense, marketing of the products is big business and you will often discover that premium quality brands are stored in the most dazzling, eye catching packaging in the pet store. Guess what? This is not cheap either.

One company who was particularly keen to advocate a change in pet feeding habits was Hills Pet Nutrition. The Science Diet was and still is often found in veterinary surgeries around the UK, although it now competes for shelf space with the brands of pet industry giants such as Pedigree and Iams.

Hills pet food range caters for the older dog, the young dog, the youthful dog, the adult dog, the fat dog, the sporty dog, the sensitive dog and more.

It must be said, the concept of paying more than ?30 for a bag of pet food (and a small one at that) then having to carefully measure out a small cup of dried pellets does not appeal to all owners. Many owners feel they are in some way not giving their dog a ‘proper’ meal unless the bowl is piled high with juicy, meaty chunks and mixer for added crunch. Remember those ads again? They made tinned dog meat look good enough for us all to eat never mind the dog!

Another problem with the concept of this type of food is cost. ?30 for a bag of food! Unheard of. But take a second to read the label. Really read the label and do the calculations. You will, more often than not, discover that the cost of feeding a so-called ‘premium’ product actually works out at a very similar daily rate to feeding a can of meat and mixer.

Not only does it cost the same, it does have the extra benefits of being easy to manage, free of odour and backed by those millions of pounds worth of scientific research.

A company who’s name is etched in the history of premium quality brands is the Procter & Gamble owned Iams Company, makers of the Eukanuba and Iams brands of dog food as well as a veterinary exclusive range of diets specifically designed to help manage disease.

Iams have been at the forefront of producing specially prepared meat based, life stage, and premium rated food since 1946.

The bright packaging and familiar logo are synonymous with the premium quality pet food market and can now been found in many pet shops and veterinary surgeries. The Iams brand is now available in major supermarkets, yet another sign of how premium products are becoming more mainstream.

Given what we now know about diet, life stage nutritional requirements and the need to keep our pets weight at the optimum level premium quality products should not be dismissed as expensive, glossy packaged luxury items.

The fact remains, these products are not as expensive as you may think, yes they do cost a lot to make and they are not all suitable to all dogs. Reading food product labels has become second nature to many people as they become more aware of the health issues associated with food. As your dog is only in a position to eat the food that is put in front of him, it would be wise to ensure his meals are as suitable as your own.

*Source PFMA.

Comments

comments

About K9 Magazine

K9 Magazine is your digital destination helping you have a happier, healthier dog. Here you'll find advice on everything from dog training to dog diet advice as well as interviews with well known dog lovers and insightful features on the broadest range of canine lifestyle topics.

5 Comments

  1. Stuart

    June 2, 2012 at 9:40 am

    Many of these premium dog foods should refrain from using the term premium. The reason for my comment is that many of them use cereal as their main ingredient. The higher it is on the list of contents the higher the percentage used. Many cereals do nothing more than pad out the product. Cereals including maize can cause problems for certain breeds of dog. Caution is the best advice for any dog owner. Select the food your dog needs carefully and a healthy future for both dog and owner will follow. They tell humans, we are what we eat, same for pet dogs.

  2. Sue

    June 2, 2012 at 11:45 am

    Many foods which claim to be ‘premium quality’ (with a price to match) are full of cheap fillers, EC permitted colours, flavours & preservatives, un-named meat source & low meat content. Bakers being a prime example of such a rubbish food. Sadly, it seems the best foods, like Orijen, are only available online

  3. Lesley

    June 21, 2012 at 8:47 am

    I agree with the above comments that many complete dried foods have poor quality fillers and use meat meal and by-products. It is really important to read the ingredients on the packet and ignore the glossy coated bouncing dog on the front of the packaging. It makes me wonder just what is the actual cost of the ingredients are per packet when you see just how much goes into advertising! Saying this there is some very good quality dried foods in the market place but you won’t find it in many pet stores, or supermarkets or come across it in big glossy advertising.

  4. Jayne Matthews

    May 20, 2013 at 7:03 pm

    A lot of the dry dog food products on the market are full of ingredients that are not only nutritionally bad for your dog, but can also cause allergies. Always look for ‘named’ meal (eg. chicken meal)and avoid ‘fresh’ meat named or otherwise. Named ‘fresh’ meat is weighed before processing so 75% of the weight is actually water. By the time this is processed it is actually a very small ingredient in the ‘good for your dog’ food. Also avoid meat and animal (named or otherwise) derivatives. These can include any and all parts of any (unnamed derivatives) animal or any part of an animal (named derivatives), meaning that feathers, wool, fur, feet, eyes etc. can all be included. Look for food with ‘Tocopherols’ included. This is a naturally occurring antioxidant which indicates a good quality food. Avoid any dog food that contains ‘unnamed’ preservatives, antioxidants, fats, etc. Basically if you want a good quality dog food, look for ‘named’ meat meal, ‘named’ fats, ‘named’ vegetables (otherwise the parts thrown away during processing for human consumption including stems, pips, etc may be used), named preservatives, additives and antioxidants or the use of ‘Tocopherols’. A lot of the cereals such as Barley can actually cause allergies or stomach upsets, so look for a low content of cereals or look for rice.

  5. Jayne Matthews

    March 25, 2014 at 10:53 pm

    Two good foods that are available at some pet stores are Arden Grange (not perfect, but better) and the one I feed my dogs called ‘Brit Care’. Burns is another one higher up the scale for good dry dog food. Always check the label.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read previous post:
Including Dog in Will
How to Include Your Dog in Your Will

Suzanne Parsonson is a lawyer with the firm Gardner Leader. She specialized in wills and probate. “Historically, the inclusion of...

Close